The Setup
McCandless-Franklin Park Ambulance Authority (MFPAA) is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) EMS provider serving McCandless, Franklin Park, Marshall, Pine, and Bradford Woods. They needed a capital campaign to fund critical equipment upgrades and operational costs — but with a modest media budget and a tight timeline.
The parameters: $3,645 total media spend. Two platforms — Meta and LinkedIn. A 30-day campaign window in October 2025. Three creative concepts to test: "911," "Impact: Chief Dell," and "Impact: Christine."
The question wasn't whether paid media could work for a small nonprofit. It was whether a disciplined, data-driven approach could outperform the "boost post and pray" strategy most nonprofits default to.
Targeting Strategy
We built the audience architecture in three layers:
- Custom lists — Uploaded lapsed donor data to create seed audiences on both platforms, then built lookalike audiences to find statistically similar prospects
- Zip code targeting — Geofenced the five townships MFPAA serves to ensure every dollar stayed within the service area
- LinkedIn precision — Targeted executive titles, Directors of Giving, foundation decision-makers, and high-net-worth individuals (HNWIs) in the region
- Meta interest layering — Stacked education professionals, healthcare workers, and community-engaged audiences within the geographic fence
The combination of first-party data (donor lists) and platform-native targeting meant we were reaching people who had both the propensity and capacity to give.
Creative That Worked
Three creatives, three different jobs:
- "911" creative — Delivered the highest click-through rate across Meta. The urgency-driven messaging cut through feed noise and drove initial engagement
- "Impact: Chief Dell" creative — Generated the most donations. Putting a real leader's face and story behind the ask created trust and converted clicks into contributions
- "Impact: Christine" creative — Strongest performer on LinkedIn with a 2.22% CTR. The personal patient story resonated with professional audiences who value narrative-driven impact
The takeaway: awareness creative and conversion creative are different jobs. Test both, then let the data allocate your budget.
The Numbers
New users accounted for 79% of all site traffic during the campaign window. Meta delivered a $1.24 CPC — 87% below the nonprofit industry benchmark. LinkedIn CTR of 1.87% came in 70% above the platform benchmark for similar campaigns.
The return: for every $1 spent on media, the campaign generated $12.93 in donations.
5 Takeaways for Nonprofits
- Budget efficiency beats budget size. $3,645 isn't a large media spend. Strategic allocation across platforms matters more than raw dollars
- Build platform-specific creative. What works on Meta won't necessarily work on LinkedIn. Christine's story proved that professional audiences respond to different emotional triggers
- Custom audiences are non-negotiable. Your donor list is your most valuable targeting asset. Upload it, build lookalikes, and layer geographic filters on top
- Real stories convert. Chief Dell's creative drove more donations than any polished brand asset. Authenticity outperforms production value for nonprofit campaigns
- Track everything. UTM parameters, conversion pixels, and donation attribution let you prove ROI — which makes the case for next year's budget
Frequently Asked Questions
How much did the MFPAA capital campaign raise?
$47,139 from 446 donors with an average donation of $105.96, compared to $95.96 the previous year.
What platforms were used for the nonprofit campaign?
Meta (Facebook + Instagram) and LinkedIn, with custom audience targeting including lapsed donor lists and lookalike audiences.
What was the return on ad spend?
$12.93 in donations for every $1 spent on media — from a total budget of $3,645.
See the full campaign results or explore how paid media can work for your organization.
View Case Study Digital Advertising